Google Shopping vs Amazon vs Shopify SEO: Which Drives More E-commerce Sales?
A data-driven comparison of the three essential e-commerce channels. Learn where to invest your product SEO efforts for maximum ROI in 2025.
Google Shopping
"Discovery-Driven Commerce"
Best For:
- Free organic product listings (Google Surfaces)
- High-intent product discovery searches
- Price comparison shoppers
- Driving traffic to your own store
- Products with unique features/specs
Amazon SEO
"Intent-Driven Marketplace"
Best For:
- Ultra-high conversion rates (9.87% avg)
- Prime members (200M+ subscribers)
- Fast time-to-sale (hours, not days)
- Products with established demand
- Leveraging FBA for fulfillment
Shopify SEO
"Brand-Owned Commerce"
Best For:
- Highest average order value ($196)
- Complete brand control and ownership
- Customer data ownership (email lists)
- Premium/lifestyle brands
- Building long-term brand equity
Head-to-Head Performance Comparison
How Google Shopping, Amazon, and Shopify stack up across 12 critical e-commerce metrics
| Metric | 🛍️ Google Shopping | 📦 Amazon SEO | 🏪 Shopify SEO |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conversion Rate | 1.91% avg | 9.87% avg Winner | 1.6% avg |
| Average Order Value | $78 | $52 | $196 Winner |
| Customer Acquisition Cost | $0-$45 (can be free) | $7-$15 (with PPC) | $60-$120 Highest |
| Time to First Sale | 2-4 weeks (if optimized) | 24-48 hours Winner | 4-12 weeks (SEO ramp-up) |
| Profit Margin | 30-50% (avg) | 15-30% (after fees) | 40-60% Winner |
| Brand Control | Medium (landing page + listings) | Low (template-based) | Full control Winner |
| Customer Data Ownership | Partial (via Google Merchant Center) | None (Amazon owns it) | Full ownership Winner |
| SEO Difficulty | Moderate (6/10) | Hard (8/10) - highly competitive | Moderate (5/10) Winner |
| Product Search Volume | 8.5B searches/month Winner | 2.4B searches/month | Varies by brand |
| Buyer Intent | Medium (researching) | Highest (ready to buy) Winner | Medium-High |
| Repeat Purchase Rate | 12% avg | 18% avg | 28% avg Winner |
| Setup Complexity | Moderate (Google Merchant Center) | Moderate (Seller Central) | Easy (plug-and-play) Winner |
ROI Analysis by Product Category
Which channel performs best for different product types
| Product Category | 🛍️ Google Shopping ROI | 📦 Amazon ROI | 🏪 Shopify ROI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Electronics | $4.20 per $1 | $6.80 per $1 Winner | $3.10 per $1 |
| Fashion/Apparel | $5.40 per $1 | $4.10 per $1 | $8.90 per $1 Winner |
| Home & Garden | $6.20 per $1 Winner | $5.80 per $1 | $4.50 per $1 |
| Beauty & Cosmetics | $4.80 per $1 | $5.20 per $1 | $9.60 per $1 Winner |
| Books & Media | $3.40 per $1 | $12.50 per $1 Winner | $2.80 per $1 |
| Jewelry & Accessories | $5.70 per $1 | $3.20 per $1 | $11.40 per $1 Winner |
| Sports & Outdoors | $7.10 per $1 Winner | $6.40 per $1 | $5.90 per $1 |
| Toys & Games | $4.60 per $1 | $9.20 per $1 Winner | $3.80 per $1 |
Which Platform Should You Prioritize?
Optimization Checklists
Step-by-step tactics to maximize sales on each platform
🛍️ Google Shopping SEO
- Set up Google Merchant Center account and verify domain
- Create product feed with all required attributes (GTIN, brand, MPN)
- Optimize product titles: Brand + Product Type + Key Feature + Size/Color
- Write descriptive product descriptions (500-1000 words)
- Use high-quality images (min 800x800px, white background)
- Implement Product schema markup on landing pages (+67% CTR)
- Set competitive pricing (Google shows price comparisons)
- Enable Google Shopping free listings (Surfaces across Google)
- Track performance in Google Merchant Center dashboard
- Fix disapproved products within 24 hours (account suspension risk)
📦 Amazon A10 Algorithm Optimization
- Research high-volume, low-competition keywords (use Helium 10 or Jungle Scout)
- Optimize title: Primary Keyword + Brand + Key Features + Size (200 chars max)
- Fill all 5 bullet points with keyword-rich benefit statements
- Write 250+ word description with secondary keywords
- Add 7+ high-quality images (lifestyle + infographics)
- Index for 200-300 keywords in backend search terms
- Price competitively (A10 heavily weights conversion rate)
- Get 15-25 reviews in first 30 days (use Amazon Vine)
- Use FBA for faster delivery and higher rankings
- Run PPC campaigns to boost sales velocity (improves organic rank)
🏪 Shopify Store SEO
- Optimize site speed (use PageSpeed Insights, target <3s load time)
- Write unique product descriptions for each SKU (no manufacturer copy)
- Optimize title tags: Product Name | Brand Name
- Create SEO-friendly URLs (/products/product-name, not /products/12345)
- Add image alt text with descriptive keywords
- Create category/collection pages targeting high-volume keywords
- Build blog content for top-of-funnel SEO (buying guides, how-tos)
- Implement Product, BreadcrumbList, and Organization schema
- Get backlinks from industry blogs, press, and review sites
- Optimize for mobile (62% of e-commerce traffic is mobile)
The Omnichannel E-commerce Strategy
Why the most successful DTC brands don't choose just one channel—and how to allocate your resources for maximum ROI
🎯 The Ideal Channel Mix
Brands selling on all 3 channels generate 4.2x more revenue than single-channel brands. Recommended allocation:
Shopify (50%): Your brand hub—highest margins, customer data, repeat purchases
Amazon (30%): Volume driver—fast cash flow, credibility signal, product testing
Google Shopping (20%): Discovery engine—free traffic, comparison shoppers, top-of-funnel
📊 The Cross-Channel Funnel
Top of Funnel: Google Shopping free listings + SEO content on Shopify attract cold traffic
Middle of Funnel: Amazon listings build trust (social proof via reviews), Google Shopping shows price comparison
Bottom of Funnel: Drive conversions on Shopify for highest margin, or Amazon for highest conversion rate
⚡ 90-Day Launch Strategy
Month 1: Launch on Amazon for fast cash flow + reviews. Set up Google Merchant Center for free listings.
Month 2: Build Shopify store with blog content. Use Amazon reviews as social proof on Shopify.
Month 3: Start Google Shopping ads. Retarget Amazon/Google visitors to Shopify for higher-margin sales.
Channel-Specific Ranking Factors
What drives visibility on each platform
🛍️ Google Shopping Factors
📦 Amazon A10 Factors
🏪 Shopify SEO Factors
Need an E-commerce SEO Strategy That Drives Sales?
Our e-commerce SEO specialists will audit your presence across Google Shopping, Amazon, and your Shopify store to create a custom omnichannel strategy that maximizes revenue and profit margins.
Get Your Free E-commerce SEO Audit →